Caguioa Doctrinal Case Digests: Civil Law

San Francisco Inn v. San Pablo City Water District (G.R. No. 204639. February 2017) Civil Law: Obligations and Contract; Invalid Obligation Whether San Francisco Inn (SFI) must pay production assessment fees to the San Pablo City Water District (SPCWD)? No. The MOA agreed to by SPCWD and SFI was not correctly executed because SPCWD did Read more about Caguioa Doctrinal Case Digests: Civil Law[…]

Caguioa Doctrinal Case Digests: Criminal Law

People of the Philippines v. Olazo (G.R. No. 220761. October 03, 2016) Criminal Law: Conspiracy Whether Charito’s argument is insufficient to prove conviction and conspiracy between him and his co-accused notwithstanding prosecution-witness turned state-witness, Joseph Oronos’ testimony that he saw him during initial planning of crime noting Charito's agreement and that it was Charito who Read more about Caguioa Doctrinal Case Digests: Criminal Law[…]

Caguioa Doctrinal Case Digest: Spouses Tapayan v. Martinez

(G.R. No. 207786. January 30, 2017) Evidence: Presumption of Regularity Whether the petitioners Tapayan presented clear and convincing evidence of fraud to refute the presumption of regularity ascribed to the Deed of Undertaking? No. Like the Deed of Undertaking in the instant case, a public document acknowledged before a notary public enjoys the presumption of Read more about Caguioa Doctrinal Case Digest: Spouses Tapayan v. Martinez[…]